School Library Journal calls Amy Alznauer’s WHERE THE WILD HORSES ARE a “lyrical…compelling, character-driven novel with emotional depth” in starred review
★ Where the Wild Horses Are by Amy Alznauer
Holiday House/Neal Porter. Oct. 2026.
“Gr 5 Up–Twelve-year-old Nashville “Nash” Stewart dreams of becoming a cowboy in rural Smoke County, PA, despite never having owned a horse of her own. Inspired by her literary hero, Mattie Ross from True Grit, Nash models herself on grit, independence, and determination well beyond her years. When she discovers a program offering yearling mustangs for a $25 adoption fee, with the promise of a $2,000 prize at a training competition in Fort Worth, TX, Nash sees her chance to change everything. Determined and resourceful, she secures not only a mustang for herself but also one for her Deaf cousin, Benedictine (“Benny”), whose summer visit rekindles a once-close bond. As the girls work to train their unpredictable horses, Nash navigates the consequences of her less-than-honest choices, the challenges of responsibility, and the complexities of family relationships. Alznauer crafts a heartfelt narrative that balances humor and poignancy, capturing Nash’s vivid imagination and fierce determination, qualities that echo the steadfast courage she admires in Mattie. The inclusion of Deaf characters adds depth and authentic representation, while the rural setting and mustang training premise provide a fresh and engaging backdrop. A quirky cast, including Wild Bill, a “wild” domesticated rabbit, adds charm and warmth. Written in a lyrical, almost poetic style, the story explores themes of identity, trust, ambition, and belonging. Nash’s voice rings true as she grapples with growing up and defining her own path.
VERDICT: A compelling, character-driven novel with emotional depth and appeal for animal lovers and fans of introspective coming-of-age stories. A strong addition to middle grade collections.”
–Patricia Snoblen